Luxury used to be a simpler equation: pay more, get better materials, better craftsmanship, better longevity. That still happens sometimes. But in the last few years, a lot of luxury pricing has moved faster than the “feel” of the product, especially in categories where brands can scale production or where the cost is mostly marketing, retail overhead, and positioning. Industry research and reporting has been pretty blunt about it: luxury has hit “price resistance,” and shoppers are questioning value more than they used to.
So here’s the useful way to think about it: some items benefit massively from designer-level patternmaking, materials, and hardware. Others don’t. If the job-to-be-done is basic (a white tee, leggings, sunglasses you’ll lose), paying a luxury premium often buys you the label, not meaningfully better performance.
This guide is about redirecting your budget into the few places luxury can actually make your life better, and saving in the places where it usually doesn’t.
Quick Answer – When Luxury Isn’t Worth It
You’re usually better off buying non-designer for:
- White tees, tanks, long-sleeves (high turnover, easy to replace)
- Trend pieces (they date fast even if they’re expensive)
- Leggings, workout tops, basic athleisure
- Socks, underwear, shapewear
- Costume jewelry and hair accessories
- Sunglasses (unless you’re buying for lens tech)
- Basic knitwear (sometimes) and most “logo knits”
- Seasonal shoes you won’t wear constantly
- Occasion-only items (you wear them once, store them forever)
If you only do one thing: stop paying luxury prices for “high-wear, low-identity” basics. Put that money toward one or two pieces that actually carry your style and get used weekly.
The decision framework: when luxury is pointless vs. when it’s smart
Before you look at categories, ask these three questions:
1) Is the item a workhorse or a statement?
- Workhorse (tees, underwear, gym gear): performance and comfort matter, branding doesn’t.
- Statement (a great coat, a signature bag, a watch): design and identity matter.
Luxury is most defensible in “statement” categories. In workhorses, you’re paying for the label more often than you want to admit.
2) Can you see the quality in 10 seconds?
If you can’t quickly spot better material, better construction, better drape, better hardware, or better finishing, luxury is probably not adding much.
3) What’s the real cost-per-wear?
A $250 tee that you treat like a $20 tee is not “investment dressing.” It’s stress.
This won’t work if you genuinely love visible branding and it makes you happy. In that case, “worth it” includes joy. Just don’t pretend it’s a value purchase.
The pieces you’re usually better off buying non-designer
1) White tees and basic tops
Why luxury isn’t worth it:
- Tees get washed constantly and lose crispness over time.
- Even high-quality cotton will eventually fade, twist, or soften.
- Fit matters more than a logo.
What to buy instead:
- Mid-priced tees known for weight, opacity, and neckline stability.
- Brands like COS have become editor favorites for solid basics at non-luxury prices.
What to look for (quick checklist):
- Fabric weight you can’t see through
- Ribbed collar that snaps back
- Shoulder seams that sit correctly
- No pulling across chest
Budget move: buy 2-3 great tees, then replace them without guilt when they’re tired.
2) Leggings and activewear basics
Why luxury isn’t worth it:
- Performance fabrics come from a limited set of textile innovations and mills.
- You’re paying for branding, not necessarily better compression, sweat-wicking, or durability.
- If you train often, you’ll rotate and replace.
What to buy instead:
- Athletic brands with proven fabric performance and consistent sizing.
- Spend on fit (rise, seam placement, waistband) rather than label.
What to look for:
- Squat-proof opacity
- Waistband that doesn’t roll
- Seams that don’t rub
- Fabric that rebounds (doesn’t bag at knees)
Trade-off with no neat solution: some “cheap” leggings pill faster, and that’s the price of saving money here. You can reduce pilling, but you won’t eliminate it.
3) Underwear, socks, shapewear
Why luxury isn’t worth it:
- These are high-friction, high-wash items.
- Comfort and fabric composition matter more than brand prestige.
- Sizing consistency matters. Designer lingerie can be beautiful but inconsistent.
What to buy instead:
- Underwear that fits your body and your laundry habits.
- Socks with reinforced heels/toes and enough elasticity to stay up.
What to look for:
- Flat seams
- Cotton gusset (for underwear)
- Elastic that doesn’t pinch
- The ability to reorder the exact same item
My honest take: I’d rather have 10 pairs of underwear that fit perfectly than 2 pairs that look fancy and annoy me all day.
4) Costume jewelry and hair accessories
Why luxury isn’t worth it:
- Most “fashion jewelry” is plated metal at every price level.
- Markup often reflects branding, not longevity.
- Hair clips and headbands get lost, tossed in bags, and snapped.
What to buy instead:
- Mid-priced jewelry with clear materials listed (sterling silver, vermeil, solid gold if you want longevity).
- For hair, buy sturdy basics and replace as needed.
What to look for:
- Clear material disclosure (not vague “metal”)
- Hypoallergenic options if your skin reacts
- Clasps that feel solid
If you want something that lasts decades, that’s a different category (fine jewelry). But for everyday “outfit jewelry,” designer is rarely the best value.
5) Sunglasses (for most people)
Why luxury isn’t worth it:
- Many designer frames are produced by large eyewear conglomerates and priced for branding.
- Sunglasses are easy to lose or sit on.
- You can get good UV protection without a luxury logo.
What to buy instead:
- Frames you’ll actually wear daily, with verified UV protection.
- Spend for comfort and fit, not brand.
What to look for:
- UV400 or 100% UVA/UVB protection
- Comfortable nose bridge
- Lenses that don’t distort
Exception: if you have sensitive eyes, want specific lens tech, or need prescription sunglasses, the lens quality and optician experience can be worth spending on.
6) Trend pieces
Why luxury isn’t worth it:
- Trends date fast no matter what you paid.
- The “outfit half-life” is short.
- Luxury brands sell trends at the highest premium, even though you’ll move on.
What to buy instead:
- Mid-priced or high-street versions.
- Or rent/secondhand if you love experimenting.
What to look for:
- Reasonable fabric for the trend’s season (don’t buy a polyester sweater trend you’ll hate wearing)
- A cut you’d still wear when the trend fades
This is one of the easiest ways to free up budget for pieces you’ll keep for years.
7) Basic knitwear (often)
Why luxury isn’t worth it (sometimes):
- “Cashmere” on the label doesn’t guarantee long fibers or low pilling.
- Care matters more than brand.
- You can find excellent sweaters outside luxury pricing.
What to buy instead:
- Well-reviewed mid-range cashmere or wool knits. Recent roundups have highlighted strong options across price tiers, including affordable picks.
What to look for:
- Fiber content and ply (when available)
- Dense knit (less see-through, better structure)
- Strong cuffs and hem
- Care instructions you’ll actually follow
A small but real limitation: if you hate hand-washing or babying knits, some premium sweaters won’t make your life better. The “best” knit is the one you’ll care for properly.
8) Occasion outfits you’ll wear once
Why luxury isn’t worth it:
- One-and-done wears destroy cost-per-wear.
- Fit is the main thing that makes you look expensive, not the label.
- You’ll likely need alterations anyway.
What to buy instead:
- A mid-priced dress or suit tailored to fit.
- Rent designer for special events if you love the idea of it.
What to look for:
- Fabric that photographs well (not shiny-cheap)
- Secure closures
- Comfortable movement
This is optional. Skip it if you attend a lot of events and repeat outfits happily. In that case, your “occasion wear” is actually a regular category, and the math changes.
Why this is happening now (and how to shop smarter because of it)
A lot of luxury categories have raised prices aggressively in recent years, and multiple industry sources say consumer perception of the price-to-value equation has weakened, especially in leather goods and fashion. Meanwhile, the resale market is growing and shoppers are getting more informed, which makes it harder for brands to rely on mystique alone.
This doesn’t mean “never buy designer.” It means buy designer where the advantages are structural (materials, construction, longevity, repairability, design that holds), and go non-designer where the item is disposable by nature.
Where I would still consider spending more (so you’re not just cutting everything)
Even though this guide is about skipping luxury, here are the categories that often do justify higher spend:
- A coat you’ll wear 100 days a year (fit, fabric, construction matter)
- Shoes you’ll wear weekly (comfort, resoling potential, leather quality)
- A signature bag if it’s truly your daily driver (or buy pre-owned)
- Fine jewelry (actual materials, not plated)
- Tailoring (not “designer,” but the biggest quality upgrade you can buy)
If you’re tempted by Chanel or Hermès specifically, the smartest “value” move is often: buy the icon you’ll wear constantly, or buy pre-owned in excellent condition. Resale data and reporting consistently show that certain classics behave differently than most fashion items.
A simple “is this worth it?” checklist you can use in any store
Before you buy, ask:
- Will I wear this at least 30 times in the next year?
- Does it feel meaningfully better than the mid-priced version in fabric and construction?
- Is the care realistic for my life (hand wash, dry clean, special storage)?
- If this gets ruined, will I be devastated or annoyed?
- Am I buying the item, or the story?
If you get two or more “no” answers, don’t pay luxury pricing.
Just a little note - some of the links on here may be affiliate links, which means I might earn a small commission if you decide to shop through them (at no extra cost to you!). I only post content which I'm truly enthusiastic about and would suggest to others.
And as you know, I seriously love seeing your takes on the looks and ideas on here - that means the world to me! If you recreate something, please share it here in the comments or feel free to send me a pic. I'm always excited to meet y'all! ✨🤍
Xoxo Dana
